Dudley as HBP??!!

[Mandy]

No: HPFGUIDX 105816

> Jake wrote:
> I think it highly unlikely that Dudley is the half blood prince.
> Harry is suppose to be a half-blood. (James-pure; Lily-muggle 
born). So, unless Vernon is a wizard (highly unlikely), Dudley, at 
best, could only be a muggle-born. <snip>


Mandy here:
I think you are confused, or I misunderstood your post.  

The blood status of a wizard child is not dependant on just the 
father, but the mother too.  

We all know Vernon is a muggle; no doubt about it, but there is the 
possibility Petunia could be a witch. Her behavior in OotP is 
extremely odd.  If Petunia does turn out to be a witch, that would 
make Dudley a half-blood.  The son of a witch mother and muggle 
father, just like Seamus.