James the Berk?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 105901

> > Pippin wrote:

huge snip.

> But it's taking Lupin into Hogsmeade 
> that is truly reprehensible. I have yet to hear any credible excuse 
> for that. 
> 
 snip.


Alla:

 Not me. I don't find their actions reprehensible at all. Stupid? 
Dangerous? I guess. But not reprehensible at all.

To me this is the classic case of noble intentions and poor execution 
of the said intentions.

They were helping a handicapped friend to bear the horror of losing 
his mind every month and becoming a dangerous beast. That is what 
real friends do.


Come to think of it, I am not even sure that I would prefer them not 
to have done it. They should not have go to Hogsmeade, absolutely.

I would want them to go to some empty areas, to the forest, I don't 
know. They were being good friends to Lupin and I admire that.