The Trichotomy-Prophecy -- the answer -- the end ......

mcmaxslb McGregorMax at ec.rr.com
Tue Jul 13 17:14:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 106004

--- Samnanya wrote:
> IMO Dumbledore's comments in the awards banquet in
> Sorcerors Stone contain THE vital clue as to
> how the series ends.
>  
> It was not an accident that Dumbledore praises Neville the
> highest by saving him for last for praise and giving him
> the 10 points for his ability to Stand Up to His Friends that
> secured the House Cup for Gryffindor during the first year.
> 
> ... Why did DD do that? What was 
> his message? What clue did JKR leave us ?
> 
> The clue that solves it all...............
>  
> Now to the prophecy. What I think happens in the end is
> that Harry confronts LV and defeats him bodily, but in the
> process the non-corporeal LV takes over Harry's body as he
> did briefly in OOP. HarryMort then raises holy hell all over
>  the wizarding world becasue noone can bring themselves to
> kill him -----  until  Neville "stands up to his friend" and
> defeats Voldemort  by defeating HarryMort in the final battle.
> 
> Neville stood up to Harry once before in an event that was
> all but forgotten, until Dumbledore pointed it out, and then
> was promptly forgotten again!
> 
> ...> NOw for the end of the series..........
> Whether Harry dies or Neville dies while freeing Harry from
> the occupancy of the Dark Lord is impossible to determine at
> this point, but I am certain that one of them dies and the
> other ends up with Hermione and lives happily ever after. 
> 
> Hermione met Neville before she met Harry and helped him
> search for Trevor. Once she met Harry their friendship
>  started to bloom and though she cared for Neville, she
> clearly fancied Harry more. If you believe in the cycle
> theory, then Neville "gets her back again" after Harry is
> gone, though she will remember Harry forever even as she
> is with Neville. 
> 
> So ..... in the end of the series ....
> 
> 1 - either Harry or Neville die, and
> 2 - Hermione ends up with the survivor.







Yeah and if the books were called 'Neville Longbottom and ...' I 
might go along with it. But the books are called 'Harry Potter 
and...' aren't they?   McMax





More information about the HPforGrownups archive