Prefects and points

vmonte vmonte at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 14 03:36:38 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 106123

Arya wrote:

I know, I know but I guess I mean I think it's a bit ludicris that
people seem to root for other characters *more* than Harry. Of course
it happens, but remember how JKR expressed surprise and a little
concern for the sanity (perhaps) of those who root for the Slytherins?
I think she's surprised there are those rooting for "the bad guys".
I don't think it's the "loyalties" she's intended the readers to have.
Sure, it is because the books have taken on a life of their
own--that's an excellent point--but it's dangerous (meaning, I think
it risks disappointment) to root for someone or anyone who is not the
protagonist.

vmonte responds:

What? Who are you tell people that they are being ludicrous because 
they root for other characters?!  I can root for all three if I want 
to! JKR expressed surprise and concern for the fans that root and 
feel drawn to Slytherin house because Slytherin's are racist slime 
(for the most part).  What in the world does Slytherin have to do 
with Ron?  Sorry, but you are not reading the books carefully.  There 
is a lot of foreshadowing going on with Ron. I agree with Del & Jem 
that Ron will surprise us in the end.  You seem to think that we are 
saying that we think Ron is going to steal Harry's thunder, but we 
are not.  The three friends are all important to the story and we can 
root for all three if we want to. 

vmonte  





More information about the HPforGrownups archive