James the Berk?
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu Jul 15 16:51:55 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 106412
Alla:
>
> If we knew that Severus only said this word once in his life
under the stress, I would not condemn him, but we KNOW that
he acted on it by joining Voldemort, so yes, I 'd say that his
actions are reprehensible.<
This seems doubtful reasoning: Snape was a racist when he
joined the Death Eaters, so he must have been one when he
used the M-word. Personally, I wouldn't like to be held
responsible for something I said while I was being dangled
upside-down by my worst enemies and my knickers were
showing.
Take Harry-- although he does take note of who's handsome
and who isn't, I wouldn't call him a lookist. And if he joined a
lookist group later, that wouldn't mean he was always a lookist at
heart.
But if Draco Malfoy were dangling him upside down and Pansy
Parkinson or Millicent Bulstrode were the one to intervene, I
wouldn't put it past Harry to tell them to keep their ugly Slytherin
noses out of his business.
And James is *so* sexist, as Harry realizes. Just because
James didn't call Lily the actual word for a woman who sells her
favors doesn't make him more respectful to Lily than Snape
was. And James wasn't being mistreated at the time.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive