Cousins by marriage ?
scoutmom21113
navarro198 at hotmail.com
Fri Jul 16 03:01:45 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 106493
Eris wrote:
(although I'm not too clear on how this 'once removed' business
works).
Bookworm:
As I understand the genealogy, Sirius and Andromeda are from the
same generation, and are first cousins they share the same
grandparents. As Andromeda's daughter, Tonks is Sirius' first cousin
once removed. I think of it as straight lines between cousins in
the same generation (first, second, etc.), and diagonal lines to
the "removed" relatives who come from different generations.
It gets really confusing when there are wide differences in age. My
second cousin once removed is my age. Her grandmother was my
mother's first cousin, so her father was my second cousin.
Del replies:
I disagree. The way Sirius said it, just after explaining that all
the pureblood families are inter-related and that this means that
the choice of partner is very limited if your kids are to be pure-
bloods too, I take it to mean that *both* Molly and Arthur are blood
relatives to Sirius.
Bookworm:
In theory, Molly and Sirius could be "cousins by marriage" if
Molly's cousin married Sirius' cousin. There would be no blood
relation between Molly and Sirius. In practice, however, you may be
right.
This could be an area JKR didn't think about in detail when she made
them cousins by marriage, but said someplace else that all the
families are related. Or it may be the relationship is so far up
the family tree that it hardly matters. (Do you think we will ever
fint out?)
Ravenclaw Bookworm
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive