Phineas Nigellus

celestina707 stargaz77 at aol.com
Fri Jul 16 03:17:37 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 106502

"eeyore5497" wrote:
>  (snip)
> Phineas does not believe that Sirius the last of the Blacks is dead;
> on p.828 it is stated that he still had not returned to his portrait 
> in Dumbledore's study. Why would she state that he did not return if 
> it wasn't significant? Did she forget, I don't think so...
> Why didn't he come back? Did he find something?


I wonder if Phineas has a portrait in the Malfoy house and/or in the 
Lestrange house, would he or could he have gone to either to find out 
more about what happened to Sirius? Just a thought.

Celestina (who knows there was a recent discussion regarding 
portraits but doesn't have time to read every post here :(


  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive