Hagrid and Mysterious Eggs
cdayr
cdayr at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 18 08:02:17 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 106761
Hi from a newbie, ready to plunge into the discussion
I have been scouring CoS in anticipation of HBP, looking for any
unresolved threads I can see, and something recently caught my
attention and imagination. I even went so far as to watch the
movie again, and a small detail about Aragog really stood out to
me and sent me scampering back to my books for the true
details.
In CoS, Aragog reveals his origins to Harry and Ron. "I was not
born in the castle. I come from a distant land. A traveler gave me
to Hagrid when I was an egg." (CoS15) Who is this traveler? Why
such a specific word- "traveler"? Why give a killer beast to a
13-year-old?
This "dangerous egg from a stranger" scenario also put me in
mind of the hooded figure in SS/PS that conveniently gives
Hagrid another egg, the dragon Norbert, and in doing so gains
information about Fluffy guarding the Sorcerer's Stone. I began
thinking- could Aragog have been given to Hagrid with a similar
motive, all those years ago? It seems a suspicious coincidence
to me that the two moments when LV/Riddle is searching for
something at Hogwart's (first the Chamber of Secrets, later the
Sorcerer's Stone) a mysterious stranger appears and gives
Hagrid his heart's desire, a Class A Non-Tradeable egg to raise
in secret.
I assume, although it is never explicitly stated, that the
mysterious "dragon dealer" in SS/PS is Quirrell/LV. What if LV
knows that Hagrid might willingly talk to a nice hooded man with
a dangerous egg because he knows he had done it 50 years
before? Was it Riddle (in disguise) who gave Hagrid the
Acromantula egg (not too likely, he's no traveler at that point)?
Or,
more likely, another wizard, someone Riddle meets or knows,
someone who has access to illegal items? Did Hagrid
inadvertently help Riddle open the Chamber of Secrets by letting
a secret slip in his excitement about the egg (as he did with the
SS)? What secrets could he have known at 13?
A side benefit of the idea that Riddle was behind or aware of
Hagrid getting Aragog is that it would explain how he knew about
Aragog's existence and knew he could frame Hagrid for the
killing. Perhaps LV's plan in SS/PS was to use Hagrid and
Norbert as scapegoats again.
I must confess that part of my current fascination with this idea
comes from the fact that this small, seemingly insignificant detail
about Aragog being passed onto Hagrid by a traveler actually
makes it, almost word-for-word, into the movie CoS. It seems a
silly expositional detail for a screenwriter to leave in during such
a dramatic and high-stakes scene. Did JKR hint that it should
stay in the movie? In the interview with JKR and Steve Kloves on
the DVD, Steve says that at least "one thing that will play later on"
stayed in the script, implying that JKR told him to leave it in when
he meant to cut it. Could it be Aragog's origins? Pure
speculation, but fun fun.
So, I throw this out to you all
who is this traveler? Why would
he
give a very dangerous egg to a 13-year-old? Are the two "egg"
plots linked? What might this tell us about Hagrid, or perhaps
Riddle, that might play a role in HBP?
Ooo, and I literally just had this thought...what if it was a time
traveler?
-CDR
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive