Re James the berk and Lily the angel

[delwynmarch]

No: HPFGUIDX 106777


Udderpd wrote :
> From the first time I read the Snape Pensive scene I have fhought 
> that it was a set up.
> 
> Snape put that particular memory in the pensive in order to 
> discredit James in Harry's eyes. He then had Draco call him out so 
> that Harry (being typical Harry) would view the memory.
> 
> Subsequently Malfoy never once mentions remedial Potions and that in
> itself is strange.

Del replies :

1. Typical Harry or not, he should not have looked in that Pensieve,
especially since he didn't know how to get out. I don't mind too much
Harry being reckless, but I DO mind him acting stupid.

2. We are never given a reason to doubt that Montague was actually
really found stuffed in a toilet at the moment Draco said. Unless you
suggest that Snape found Montague first (he'd been missing for 2 weeks
if I remember well), and then stuffed him himself in that toilet,
before giving his instructions to Draco ? Could be, but I really doubt it.

Del