[HPforGrownups] Re: "I'm not proud of it"

[Miss Melanie]

No: HPFGUIDX 106854

Anastasia wrote: 
If Ginny was compared to Mrs Weasley, I would think more about her 
caring for others than her habitude of shouting if there's anything 
wrong. 
When you love somebody you see his best sides, not his worst.
Especially if this person has died several years ago. Therefore, it 
is only natural that Sirius and Lupin talk affectionately about 
James, most of us would wonder if they didn't. They were like 
brothers! 
Additionally, we don't know how much James has changed after that 
Pensieve scene. After all, it was enough to become Head Boy. Could 
you imagine Lily dating James if he hadn't changed?

 

My reply:  No Lily wouldn't have given James the time of day, much like she is doing in this scene.  She is disguested by his affections.  Teenages as much as you all would hate to admit otherwise do change, I think often it happens when something life altering happens.  I don't know what this could have been for the marauders but it is likely that something did happen.  

And in regards to Lily do you honnestly think she would appoint Sirius guardian of Harry if he hadn't changed either?

~Melanie




		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Vote for the stars of Yahoo!'s next ad campaign!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]