New JKR FAQ Poll: Which is significant?
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Tue Jul 20 13:25:00 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 107025
Valky:
> > Of course there is the decided possibility that they are,
actually, *all* unimportant questions with strictly non-spoiler
answers. That, I have considered, and yet, I still have an inkling
that JKR doesn't play that way. One of them, surely, is a valuable
clue, but which one I am hesitant to guess, for now.
> > If someone can remember fully what were the other two questions
> that JKR offered on the Mark Evans Poll, which one of those do we
think *now* that we might have missed our chance on? I think that
might help us to wrangle a Really Canon Brilliant answer out of the
great one this time. LOL
Alla:
> Hey, Valky! Oh, I like the idea that one of the FAO questions does
> hide important clue much better than the idea than none of the
> answers will be important anyway.
>
> If I remember correctly two other questions asked whether Snape is
> really Perseus Evans and whether Sirius is realy dead (sob..)
> I think you know which one of them I would love to hide a clue. :o)
Jen: Maybe your right, Valky! I figured since JKR was picking the
questions they wouldn't hold important clues, but...
Well, JKR said in an interview right after OOTP that she 'killed' a
character in it, so it's pretty clear Sirius is dead (but seems
certain to still be part of the plot). And we all know what happened
to Mark Evans. Could that mean *gasp* there's something to the
Perseus Evans = Severus Snape anagram?!?
As for the new poll, I voted for "Remember my last" because I'm just
very curious what that refers to, and I think the answer holds a
clue to why Petunia agreed to take Harry in and/or how much contact
she's had with the WW.
The Percy one, even if he is a spy, doesn't mean much for the
overall plot. Personally, I think Wormtail has gone AWOL from
Voldemort, but we'll find out in Book 6 anyway, when JKR promised
he'll return. So unless there's a really surprising answer to one of
these questions.....I'm sticking to what's behind Door #3!
Jen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive