Quick question re: Lupin's resignation . . .

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 107212

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mayeaux45" <mayeaux45 at y...> 
wrote:


snip.


Also to 
> further my point that Snape had relatively nothing to do with 
> Lupin's resignation, there is the line spoken by Lupin in the PoA 
> movie "It would seem that *someone* has revealed the nature of 
> my...condition".  We already know that JKR reads over the scripts 
> and trust Steve Kloves immensely, so I believe that particular line 
> to be 'telling' (maybe even for books 6&7). Because if not 
> Snape...then WHO?  Hermione surely wouldn't have told anyone.  Is 
> there someone at Hogwarts that we have not yet been introduced to?  
> Only time will tell...



Alla:

Interesting. I cannot say that I am convinced yet, but I am at least 
ready to listen. Who knows, maybe that line is one of the 
foreshadowing hints JKR was talking about.

I don't think JKR reads the scripts though. With that much material 
cut from the movie, I doubt it. Although I am surethat she gives 
general approval.

But who do you think it was ? Voldemort agent in Hogwarts? Who could 
that be? Who may know about the nature of Lupin's illness, besides 
parties involved int he Shrieking Shack event?.

Nah, I still think that dear Severus executed his revenge over poor 
Remus. Bad, Bad Snape! Left Remus without any possibility to earn a  
living. (Hey, Pippin! :o)


Although, when I reread Hagrid's quote, I am inclined to agree with 
Ava - it could be read that Snape told Slytherins that Lupin is 
resigning because he is a werewolf (after somebody else already 
slipped it)


But, please, please convince me who that "anonymous person" can be.



Alla,