Still wondering why Snape trusts DD! (was: James the Berk?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 107214


Carol earlier:
> > Moreover, he can't know that Snape is an occlumens or Snape would 
be unable 
> > to spy on him or observe him or attend meetings (whatever he's 
doing) 
> > without giving himself away.


Carolina replied: 
> I can't agree with this. If Voldemort is using Snape as a spy, he 
should know 
> that he needs to be an occlumens to do that work. One can't be 
under the nose 
> of a legilimens for 14 years without being an occlumens and 
Voldemort should 
> know, or should be asking himself why DD hasn't detected him in 14 
years if 
> he is not one.  
> 



Alla:

Good point, Carolina. I also tend to think that Voldemort knows about 
Snape being an Occlumenc. He has to. If nothing else, Voldie would 
have learned about it when he would try to read Snape's mind and 
could not. That is one of the reasons why i don't believe that Snape 
does direct spying. On the other hand if he spied on Lucius mind by 
using his legilimenc abilities, that I see as more porbable version 
of the events.