Voldemort and the Prophesy --OOP

rebeccatrishel trishel2 at hotmail.com
Fri Jul 23 07:15:36 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 107378

kacie0223 wrote (about others than Dumbledore and Trelawney knowing 
the prophecy):
> I suspect that they may be or possibly DD has filled in key members 
> of the order. 

Rebecca Trishel says:
Well, Trelawney has no memory of either of her "true" predictions, so 
she actually doesn't know. DD knows. A "spy" listening in on the 
conversation in the Hogshead pub knows part of it. Voldie knows part. 
I think that Sirius didn't know the prophecy, as he told Harry to 
grab it and run in OotP. If he knew what was in it, he wouldn't have 
bothered. So possibly only Harry and DD know all of the prophecy.

I've got to say something here, off-topic: Dumbledore should talk to 
McGonagall more. He's a bad communicator with her. She didn't know 
about giving Harry to the Dursleys, or that the Potters were really 
dead, or (apparently) anything about the Prophecy ... tsk, tsk. 
Dumbledore, shame on you. :)
--Rebecca Trishel






More information about the HPforGrownups archive