Resolving "In Essence Divided" With The Prophecy

entropymail entropymail at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 23 16:44:19 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 107447

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dcgmck" <dolis5657 at y...> wrote:
> "entropymail" wrote: [major snip, sorry; good stuff that]
> 
> > Clearly, Voldemort cannot live as a whole being while Harry 
> survives, stubbornly holding onto Voldie's other half.  Harry, as 
> well, cannot survive as a whole being as long as half of Voldemort 
> takes up half of Harry's mind.  Voldemort must kill Harry in order to 
> regain his full spirit.  As for Harry, either Harry or Voldie's 
> spirit will ultimately gain control over his mind.  Neither of these 
> two competing forces can fully survive while it is at odds with the 
> other. <
> 
> 
> dcgmck:<snip> I like how it plays.  This understanding works with
the train 
> of thought that JKR will find a way for Harry to resolve his dilemma 
> without stooping to killing, the false dichotomy he was last 
> entertaining in the midst of a full-blown attack of puberty.  

With this in mind, I've been practically tripping over references to 
things being split  or paired.  Here are a few on my mind:

1.  Fred and George: They are not just twins. They seem to be wholly
of the same mind; finishing each others' thoughts and such.  They can
truly be described as one mind in two bodies.

2.  Don't know how I neglected to  mention it the first time around,
but the green-smoke snake which issues from Dumbledore's instrument as
he murmurs "But in essence divided?"  It splits into two snakes in
answer to his question.

3. When Voldie possesses Harry in the MOM: "...they were fused
together, bound by pain...."

4.  And where is it that Harry feels as if his head will split open,
split in two, or some such thing? I know I've seen it...

;; Entropy ::





More information about the HPforGrownups archive