Apparate into Hogwarts? (was Re: Attack on Hogwarts?)

ariston3344 ariston3344 at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 23 16:45:33 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 107454

Rebecca Trishel wrote:
> The "you can't Apparate into Hogswarts grounds" is a really
> important HP rule that has been followed in all the books.
> Two exceptions: Dobby apparates, and so does the Knight Bus, as I 
> remember. Maybe Hogwarts will be attacked by apparating house-
> elves in buses.

ariston:
LOL!  And don't forget phoenixes.  So maybe Hogwarts will be 
attacked by house-elves bearing phoenixes (is that like Greeks 
bearing gifts?) riding in Knight Buses. :)  Except for the fact that 
phoenixes are peaceful and seem to be generally good creatures, so I 
guess DEs and evil house-elves wouldn't get along with them too well.

All this makes me wonder, though, why Quirrell didn't have Malfoy 
just send *Dobby* after the Stone in book 1.  What a job JKR has!  
It's virtually impossible to keep track of all the loose threads...

-ariston







More information about the HPforGrownups archive