Doesn't Voldemort know about Snape's loyalty?

nkafkafi nkafkafi at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 24 05:19:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 107529

Neri wrote:
> But I do believe that Snape didn't completely wormed his way back
> into Voldy's good graces. The proof: he didn't know about the plot
> to lure Harry to the DoM, and he wasn't ordered to do it himself,
> although from Voldy's point of view he was perfectly situated to
> do just that.

Ariston:
Hmmm... well, if Snape *is* acting as a double agent (yes, it's a
big if, but I still think it's an open possibility, see below) -- if
he is acting as a double agent, then both sides realize that he has
to look like he's accommodating to the other side. So it wouldn't
make sense, for example, for him to be the one to actively lure
Harry to the DoM. <snip>

Neri again:
I also tend to the possibility that Snape is a double agent, and in 
general I agree with what you wrote. However, this argument doesn't 
hold anymore if one of the sides believes it's end game. In Voldy's 
case, he thinks (and with a very good reason) he can capture both the 
irking Potter and the Prophecy in a single move. This looks very much 
like the decisive blow that will win the war for him, and for such an 
objective blowing Snape's cover would be worthwhile. So it seems 
Voldy values Snape enough not to kill him, but not enough to trust 
him with the most important missions. 

Neri  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive