[HPforGrownups] Re: Most burning Snape question?

[A. Delavan]

No: HPFGUIDX 107561



> Laura:
> > > I've already decided I'm asking her a question
> on Snape as 
> not many  people ask good Snape questions ... This
> is what I've 
> got so 
> far:
> > > 
> > > 1) Is Snape a pure blood?
> > > 2) Why did he join/leave the Deatheaters?
> > > 3) Has he ever been married/engaged?
> > > 4) Will he ever get the DADA position?
> > > 5) Why did he flinch in GOF when Lucius was
> named as a 
> DE in the  hospital wing?<<
> <BIG SNIP>

A Goldfeesh says,
If I had your opportunity I might ask "Are memories in
the pensieve objective or subjective?"

If JKR didn't do an "Erm, I can't say" we'd get
(hopefully) an end to the argument of "it's all
Snape's point of view- James and Sirius are not the
bullies the pensieve scene shows them to be." In
addition to ending the argument, we'd know if it were
objective or not. *s*

A. Goldfeesh
(who is sure it is objective and can't see how two
ganging up on one at the same time can be seen as
anything but bullying)


		
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
New and Improved Yahoo! Mail - Send 10MB messages!
http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail