How should Harry deal with Snape?
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Mon Jul 26 18:35:24 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 107751
> Alla:
>
> No, there is nothing submissive in doing that, BUT for example
when teacher starts insulting your dead parents (No matter how
right this teacher turns out to be ), it is not the time to be quiet.<
Correct me if I'm wrong, but has Snape *ever* mentioned Harry's
parents in the classroom? Snape's entitled to his personal
opinion as expressed in the The Shrieking Shack and
Grimmauld Place, and certainly inside his own thoughts (where
Harry intruded without permission.)
The closest Snape came to it was when Harry had just told
Snape five lies in a row about not being in Hogsmead.
(PoA- ch. 14) T. Agreed, Snape lost it, but I can understand why.
The truth was desperately important, not least because the way
that Harry got *out * of the castle just might be the way that
Sirius is getting in. It was not the time to be concerned about
Harry's feelings.
We know there are channels to use when a teacher behaves
unacceptably. Draco used them against Hagrid. Harry could
have complained to the board of governors. Snape even invited
him to go to Dumbledore. But of course Harry couldn't do that
because he'd been breaking rules for no good reason and didn't
want to take his medicine. Tough.
You have a good point that Snape needs to stop seeing Harry as
his father. But IMO, actions speak louder than words.
If Harry wants Snape to see that he's not arrogant, he might try
demonstrating a little humility. That is not the same thing as
being humiliated, and I would like to see Harry realize that
sometime. I agree there would be justice in Snape improving
first. OTOH, what if he doesn't?
Should Harry decide to spend his whole life waiting for Snape to
make the first move? What about being pro-active? Or at least
realizing that Snape is going to stay at Hogwarts and Harry is
going to leave--this too shall pass.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive