How should Harry deal with Snape
cubfanbudwoman
susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Tue Jul 27 20:44:02 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 107904
dzeytown:
> > Oh dear, I hope things don't get this insipid. After five years
> > of abuse Harry decides to take a page out of "An Officer and a
> > Gentleman."
> >
> > Snape has been the one who has abused Harry consistently for five
> > years. It is to *Snape* that the consequences and changes must
> > come home to roost, *not* to Harry.
Alla:
> Oh, I agree, Dzeytoun, I do, but I am afraid that JKR will make
> Harry to do a first step, no matter how unrelistic and unsatisfying
> TO ME it will look.
>
> At least I hope that some kind of cataclysmic event will make him
> do it (DD death? As Boyd suggested)
>
> I am hoping not to see Harry's sudden realisation that Snape is an
> OK guy.
SSSusan:
I *should* stay out of this and let Pippin respond, but I must ask:
Are you *sure* what Pippin described was all about Harry realizing
Snape is an OK guy?? That's not how I read it at all. In fact, I
don't think Harry *will* think that; rather, I think he will just
come to a place where he can master his feelings enough to SET THEM
ASIDE around Snape much better than he has been able to before. He
can still loathe things about Snape; he can still despise his
treatment of people; he can still think he's not okay; and yet
acknowledge that he's an ally in an important way.
Siriusly Snapey Susan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive