McGonagall and Flitwick

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Thu Jul 29 13:25:43 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108072

-Meri wrote:
> 
> Yes, but remeber back then the Order wasn't a private army, it was 
> just a collective of people who resisted LV. I would bet that 
there 
> were a lot of people involved in the struggle, including MM and 
> Flitwick, that weren't present for that photo. 


Potioncat:
Oops, private army probably wasn't the best choice of words.  The 
Order of the Phoenix is a group of organised resistance fighters. 
(does that sound correct?)

My point is really that we know "some" of the Order members from 
before and "some" of the Order members now.  But we do not know if 
either McGonagall (member now) or Flickwick were in the Order 
earlier.  And their not being in it would only mean they weren't in 
it. Snape worked with DD against LV, but he wouldn't  be considered 
a member of the Order at that time. He is now.

Does that make sense?

Potioncat





More information about the HPforGrownups archive