Snapes Attitude towards the Students

gelite67 gelite67 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 29 23:37:12 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108156

stephenflynn001 at y...> wrote:
> > Hi all,
> > 
> > Does anybody know if Snape has every been disciplined for the 
> actions 
> > and behaviour towards not just Harry but all the students outside 
> of 
> > Slytherin.  It seems ridiculous that a person with his temperment 
> and 
> > obvious chip on his shoulder should be responsible for childrens 
> > development.
> > 
> > SF
> 
> sad1199 replies:
>  I don't remember Snape ever being disciplined. But, then again, I 
> don't remember ANY students going to the proper authorities about 
> him. The only students he is purposely worse than nasty to are 
Harry 
> and Neville. 

Angie adds:
 Snape was particularly vicious to Hermione when her teeth grew 
abnormally large from a curse Malfoy put on Hermione and Snape said 
he couldn't see any difference.  That's just plain cruel.  The 
students shouldn't have to report him.  DD seems to know everything 
else that goes on.  Between the pictures, the ghosts, and DD's 
ability to be invisible, as well as his knowledge of Snape and of 
things in general, I just can't see how DD doesn't know about Snape's 
viciousness.  Snape may be excellent with potions and may be a true 
DD supporter, but unless his nastiness is a cover for something else 
to which we are not yet privvy, he shouldn't be allowed to teach.  
Maybe we are to assume that DD brought Snape into HW for a very good 
reason which has yet to be revealed.  Which leads me to wonder what 
Snape's profession was before he was a teacher?






More information about the HPforGrownups archive