The Titlings

amphibi_pro amphibi_pro at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 30 08:12:14 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 108179

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Cathy Drolet" <cldrolet at s...> 
wrote:
> It wasn't the Goblet of Fire that brought Harry to LV... 'twas the 
Triwizard Cup.  The Goblet of Fire was the thing that the students 
who wanted to enter the Triwizard Tournament had to put their names 
in. It was shut back in its casket on October 31st after the fire 
went out...after the names were spewed out of it.

ChrisP here:
Lol, yes, yes my bad, I'm sorry. I haven't read it again for a while 
so I mixed up. However, forgive my stubbornness, it eventually bring 
Harry to Voldemort. After all, Harry won't be able to touch the 
triwizard cup unless he get through the goblet first. Although, I 
wonder why did Jo use the goblet of fire as the title when it's role 
merely to shout Harry's name? Maybe 'cause it was the start point, 
just like sorcerer stone?

> DuffyPoo now:
> So who do we have to deal with...new in the third book:  
> 
> Stan Shunpike - Knight bus conductor
> Ernie Prang - Knight bus driver
> Florean Fortescue - owner of the ice cream shop in Diagon Alley
> Remus Lupin - DADA professor
> Sibyll Trelawney - Divination professor
> Peter Pettigrew - traitor
> Madam Rosemerta - Landlady of the Three Broomsticks
> Cedric Diggory - Captain of the Hufflepuff team - dead now though
> Cho Chang - Ravenclaw seeker
> Roger Davies - Ravenclaw Captain 
> Waldon Macnair - MoM executioner & DE
> Some old committee member with no name
> A boatload of Dementors
> No first years are listed by name because Harry & Hermione missed 
> the sorting that year
> 
> <snip> 
> If JKR truly means Prince as being male...that leaves out Trelawney, 
> Chang and Madam Rosemerta. Of the lot that's left, Roger Davies and 
> Remus Lupin? Lupin has already made a comeback in OotP.


chrisp now:
No, I don't think HBP is on the list you made. Again, if it is a 
pattern, then HBP should be mentioned as an insignificant character. 
Who would have thought that young Sirius who gave his flying bicycle 
to Hagrid would one day turn out to be Harry's godfather? Sigh, too 
bad the book is not in my possession now, I want to search it myself.. 
anyway, good job on the list.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive