Re: Snapes access to DD office? (was: Snape's part in death of Sirius )
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Fri Jul 30 15:49:16 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108197
> Neri:
> As another interesting subthread from the original discussion, I
> believe Snape did have access to DD's office when DD was not in
> Hogwarts. The reason is that in the first Occlumency lesson, Harry
> recognizes the Pensieve Snape uses as DD's Pensieve. The last (and
> memorable) Occlumency lesson is cosiderable time after DD left
> Hogwarts, and his office is said to be shut (Umbridge certainly
> doesn't manage to get in), but the Pensieve is still in Snape's
> possession. But in Ch. 37 when Harry is sent back to DD's office
from the MoM, he sees the Pensieve in DD's office. How did it got
there and what does this signifies?
>
Potioncat:
I took, from the very first time I read it, to be an assumption on
Harry's part that it was DD's Pensieve. Do we know if it was ever
confirmed. I will admit that I am also assuming. What do the rest
of you think? Is this DD's or Snape's?
I also thought that one of the Portraits made the comment that if
Harry was in DD's office, that DD must be back. That made me think
that no one but DD had access to the office.
Potioncat (apologizing for not double checking canon on this.)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive