Chamber of Secrets - The Unexplained
fiondavhar
enigma_only at hotmail.com
Sat Jul 31 01:38:42 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108249
Like many others here, I have just re-read Chamber of Secrets,
looking for clues and the elusive "discovery" Harry made that will be
so important to the 6th book. I decided to focus on the apparently
insignificant things that could become hugely significant given the
right circumstances. Here are some of the things that stuck out to me:
1) The scorch marks on the floor after the first attack.
- Obviously, these might have been caused by the Basilisk, but they
were not mentioned at any of the other attack scenes. Could there be
any other reason for their presence, or the lack of explanation in
regards to them? I for one don't recall "leaves scorch marks on the
ground" as being part of the description of the basilisk.
2) Aragog's blindness.
- I couldn't discern the significance of this. Why would it matter
that Aragog be blind?
3) Tom Riddle's "bravery".
- When Harry and Tom speak in the chamber of secrets, Tom says that
he was considered to be very brave. The word is stressed, actually,
written in italics (pg 230, Canadian soft-cover). My question is,
since Tom was implying that he was thought to be very brave BEFORE
having captured Hagrid, WHY was he considered brave? What sort of
things had he done to earn that reputation, and could they be
important to the plot of the story?
4) The use of the word "ancestor" as opposed to "descendant" in
regards to Riddle and Slytherin, in Harry's conversation with
Dumbledore.
- On page 245 of the Canadian soft-cover edition, Dumbledore tells
Harry that Voldemort is the last remaining ancestor of Salazar
Slytherin. The last remaining ANCESTOR. Not DESCENDANT. Is this a
flint? Or could there be some strange reversal of time at work?
Because, of course, an ancestor is someone you are descended from -
so Tom should be Slytherin's DESCENDANT, not his ancestor. Hmmm.
Anyone have any thoughts on any of these?
Bonny
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive