Harry's Discovery in CoS

[celestina707]

No: HPFGUIDX 108309

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Dane" <jaycat at k...> wrote:

>    There has been a lot of talk about what Harry's discovery in 
> Chamber of Secrets was and its significance to the HBP.  There is 
> only one real discovery that I can think of in CoS, and that was 
> Harry's finding out that Filch is a squib.  I don't know if this 
has 
> any bearing on the HBP, but think about it.  Filch is kind of fishy 
> as a squib...his cat is named Mrs. Norris (is this for a specific 
> reason)...and JKR said on her site that the families of the 
teachers 
> will be factors in books 6 and 7. Or maybe I'm just stupid.



Celestina:  Just wanted to add a little something  to this that my 
daughter actually pointed out to me a couple of days ago.  Argus 
Filch/Arabella Fig. Both are squibs, both have cats, and have the 
same initials. 

Umm, not sure if this has any bearing on anything, but just wanted to 
add to this discussion regarding Filch. 

I am one who thinks perhaps Filch would be the one who learns magic 
later in life, after all, he is trying to isn't he? But not sure 
about him as the HBP, I would need to see more to support that 
theory. I'm still leaning in the Dumbledore direction for HBP.