Clues to 6&7 in POA film

pippin_999 foxmoth at qnet.com
Sat Jun 5 17:01:33 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100097

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Jason" 
<shrtbusryder2002 at y...> wrote:

> 
> Jason:
>    I took JKRs statement into the theater with me and looked 
> for "clues" to books 6 and 7. First one that jumped at me was 
of  course the scene on the bridge with Lupin and Harry. Lily was 
there  for him when few others were? Was there a falling out of 
the  marauders?  I guess Lilys kindness may be something 
important.<

A falling out indeed. That much of EverSoEvil!Lupin (post 39362) 
is canon. There was a time when both James and Sirius 
believed that Lupin was the spy--that was why they didn't tell him 
about the secret keeper switch.  But, oh horrors! what if Lily 
couldn't believe it, and to prove her trust, revealed the 
secret-keeper switch to ESE!Lupin! He, of course, took it straight 
to Voldemort, and asked for Lily's life in exchange, convincing  
himself that it was the only way to save her. Besides, if Sirius 
was a spy as well, as Lupin seems to have believed, then 
Voldemort was going to find out anyway. 

 No wonder Lupin was so worried about what Harry overheard 
as he relived his parents' deaths. What if Lily had revealed in her 
last moments  that Lupin knew about the  switch! "You heard 
James?" indeed! Harry never does tell Lupin that he heard Lily 
speaking, does he?...only that he could hear her being 
murdered.

Will Harry have to find a way to endure a Dementor's presence 
without passing out or letting it take his soul so that he can at 
access all the memories of his mother's death and find out what 
she was saying with her last breath?

And innocent Cuaron thought he was merely taking poetic 
license. Hah!

Pippin
who isn't saying anything about the vampire clues because she 
doesn't think they were inadvertent, one bit.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive