[HPforGrownups] Possible Spoilers (was Re:] Clues to 6&7 in POA film)

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 100108


[Lee]:
Why? In the book, Lupin indicated that he saw Peter's name on the map which
was what surprised him most and one of the reasons he ran to investigate.
So Peter showing up on the map in the film is correct.

Cheers,

Lee :-)

Sherry

I was thinking about this yesterday.  Whenever Harry used the map in the
book, it was to go to Hogsmeade.  at those times, Ron was already in
Hogsmeade, wasn't he?  So Harry wouldn't have seen Peter's name because
Peter was with Ron.  after Peter faked his death by Crookshanks, we don't
know where he was, except that he ended up in a bottle in Hagrid's hut on
the fateful day.  I think he must have been off the grounds in some way
every time Harry looked at the map, otherwise, Harry would have seen his
name.  Unless Harry just wasn't looking in the right place, being focused on
who might catch him sneaking out, not on who might be wandering on the
grounds.  If that makes any sense.

sherry G