Clues to books 6&7 in POA (spoilers and clues)

littleleahstill cmjohnstone at hotmail.com
Sun Jun 6 12:10:43 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100174

Vmonte wrote:
(snip)

>Why did they change what happened in Trelawny's class? In the movie
>Trelawny tells Hermione that she has the soul of an old maid.

>Where did that come from? And why say that in particular? Is it
>foreshadowing Ron's death (if you believe in the Hermione/Ron ship)?
>Also if Ron=DD, does Hermione=MM? Sorry, I couldn't help myself.

Leah, in strictly not serious vein writes:

Does this mean Trelawny herself is not an old maid? What is her 
passionate past? Is she one of the married teachers of whose 
existence JKR once hinted?  Is this why DD is so keen she remains at 
Hogwarts?

And I have to confess I've always wondered about Hermione= MM since I 
first came across the Ron=DD theory, based IIRC on the game of chess 
played in PS/SS.  But Ron is only knocked out of play in the chess- 
it's Hermione who gets sent back via the potions in the next task.

Leah   






More information about the HPforGrownups archive