Priori Incantatem - further thoughts (longish)

snow15145 snow15145 at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 7 02:07:53 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100213


> geoff banister said:
>snip<
 The other is that slightly differing forms of the 
> spell wording are mentioned. Amos Diggory uses "Prior Incantato" 
> which sounds suspiciously like a genitive whereas "Priori 
> Incantatem" - which is not actually heard being used in this book - 
> looks like an accusative. I am trying to remember whether any of 
the 
> spells used in the books appear in more than one version and, if 
so, 
> if that affects the result.
> 
> Anyone care to pick holes or add their two pennyworth?

Snow replies:
I had also wondered about the difference between the spellings and or 
meanings of Priori Incantato vs. Priori Inacntatem. The only 
reference that I can think of that might relate would be parcel mouth 
and parcel tougue. 
Priori Incantato is to Priori Incantatem as Parcel Mouth is to Parcel 
Tongue.

Don't know if that helps but thats what I thought! 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive