POA List of Differences (spoilers)

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Jun 7 17:12:33 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100276

snipping body of post.
Mike Feemster wrote a list of differences:
> 
> 7) Choir led by Flitwick.

Potioncat
I didn't read the credits, (was too busy watching footprints) Was he 
listed as Flitwick?  In the IMDB he was listed as "a wizard"  So I 
was  wondering why, if they had Warwick Davies, they didn't have 
Flitwick.

> Mike:
 29) Snape places himself between the trio and Lupin as
> a werewolf.

Potioncat:
I liked the "idea" of this as sort of confirming that Snape was 
there to protect the trio and this seemed the easiest way of doing 
it. Particularly sense we don't have  him conjuring stretchers.  
Although I'm not sure it really worked.

 
> 34) Goyle is missing from a few Slytherin scenes.
 Potioncat:  I was wondering if "Slytherin boy" was Theo?  I also 
noticed Goyle's absence.

> 
Mo: wrote 
>snip
> But, I do have to include that I really liked how
> Snape protected the children when Lupin turned into a
> werewolf.  I think that gives us a little more insight
> into his character.  As someone else said, Snape may
> be a good guy, even if he isn't a nice guy.
> 
Potioncat:
Yes, again I liked it in theory.  What I did like was he came out 
from the willow bellowing "There you are Potter!"  and immediately 
began protecting them.  However, I think had canon Snape been 
protecting them he would have had a spell to at least attempt on the 
werewolf.

Potioncat






More information about the HPforGrownups archive