POA List of Differences (spoilers)

[Stephanie]

No: HPFGUIDX 100300

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Ms Mo Me <fauntine_80 at y...> 
wrote:
> Message: 1
>    Date: Sun, 06 Jun 2004 23:40:49 -0000
>    From: "mikefeemster" <mikefeemster at y...>
> Subject: POA List of Differences (spoilers)
> 
> Given what JKR has said about the movie, specifically
> the two things 
> that foreshadowed something in book 6 or 7, I decided
> to make a list 
> of things that I noticed were different from the book.
>  I don't 
> think I got everything but I did get quite a bit.  Let
> me know what 
> you think.
> 
> 1) Harry is not writing his history class essay but is
> looking at a 
> book on how to do spell motions.
> 
> 2) Knight bus shrunken head.
> 
> 3) Tom instead of Fudge meets Harry.
> 
> 4) Fudge has all of Harry's books.
> 
> 5) Arthur tells Harry instead of Harry overhearing
> Molly and Arthur.
> 
> 6) Mrs. Weasley runs to the train with Scabbers.
> 
> 7) Choir led by Flitwick.
> 
> 8) Fat Lady singing (trying to break a glass) before
> opening the 
> door.
> 
> 9) Horseplay in the dormitory with some kind of candy
> that allows 
> the eater to make certain noises.  Seamus: monkey,
> Neville: 
> elephant, Ron: lion, Harry: train(?).
> 
> 10) In Hagrid's class everybody backs away except
> Harry, in the book 
> Harry steps forward.
> 
> 11) Bogart scene: Ron gives spider roller skates,
> Parvati's bogart 
> is a snake instead of a mummy.  Harry actually
> participates and 
> Lupin steps in.
> 
> 12) Lupin/Harry bridge scene.  Lupin explains Lily and
> James and 
> says that Harry is more like them than he ever knows.
> 
> 13) When Snape takes over for Lupin / Malfoy's art.
> 
> 14) Harry is number seven when he is playing Qudditch.
> 
> 15) Fat Lady hides behind a hippo(?) in another
> picture.
> 
> 16) While they are all sleeping in the great hall,
> Snape asks 
> Dumbledore if Potter should be warned.
> 
> 17) Fred and George know of Harry's invisibility
> cloak.
> 
> 18) Harry pulls Malfoy into the perimeter of the
> Shrieking Shack's 
> fence.
> 
> 19) Harry cries on a rock and is comforted by
> Hermione.
> 
> 20) Harry thinks of his mom and dad talking to him to
> fight the 
> dementor (bogart).
> 
> 21) Hagrid throws rocks on the lake.
> 
> 22) Hermione punches Malfoy instead of slepping him.
> 
> 23) Hermione hugs Ron when the trio thinks that
> Buckbeak is executed.
> 
> 24) Whomping Willow attacks Harry and Hermione and
> then throws them 
> down the hole.
> 
> 25) Pettigrew runs before being forced to show
> himself.
> 
> 26) Harry uses Hermiones wand to disarm Snape.
> 
> 27) There is a piano in the Shrieking Shack.
> 
> 28) Sirus and Hermione try to talk to Lupin as he
> transforms and 
> After he transforms.
> 
> 29) Snape places himself between the trio and Lupin as
> a werewolf.
> 
> 30) Soul ball (?) comes out of Sirius's mouth.
> 
> 31) Hermione throws rock and howls after they go back
> in time.
> 
> 32) Buckbeak defends Harry and Hermione from Lupin i
> werewolf form.
> 
> 33) Harry's patronus emits a pulsating wave of light
> that chase off 
> the dementors.
> 
> 34) Goyle is missing from a few Slytherin scenes.
> 
> 
>    I hope this gives something for all of us to think
> about until 
> book 6 comes out.
> 
> Mike
> 
> 
> I think that there were a lot of differences due to
> the fact they had to put the book into only a two hour
> movie.  However, I did notice the repeated play of the
> headless hunt throughout the movie.  I was curious in
> the second movie why they had left out the deathday
> party and the headless hunt.  I was curious as why,
> then, this was added in the third movie.  Could it be
> foreshadowing something?  I really can't come to any
> conclusions.  Maybe they just put it in because it
> looked cool, or maybe there is more to the headless
> hunt???
> I'll have to ponder this a little longer and write
> back at a later time. This is the first time I heard
> of clues in the third movie relating to other books. 
> But, I do have to include that I really liked how
> Snape protected the children when Lupin turned into a
> werewolf.  I think that gives us a little more insight
> into his character.  As someone else said, Snape may
> be a good guy, even if he isn't a nice guy.
> 
> ~Mo
> 
> Steph here:

I feel like everyone is forgetting how many times Harry is told he 
has his mother's eyes in the movie..it is a clue we are a familiar 
with, but it's forshadowing none the less.  I think that whole scene 
with Lupin and Harry is really important.  Lupin mentions how Lily 
sees the beauty and greatness in people, even when they don't see it 
themselves.  I thought that was especially important considering 
that it was never mentioned in the books.  We have never been let in 
on Lily's relationship with James's friends.
> 
> 
> 	
> 		
> __________________________________
> Do you Yahoo!?
> Friends.  Fun.  Try the all-new Yahoo! Messenger.
> http://messenger.yahoo.com/