The Movie vs. JKR?

[Firedancer]

No: HPFGUIDX 100335

God love you, hon'.  My problem is that I feel exactly the way you do, but I
find myself sticking up for the movie anyway, as I've said before.  Now, I'm
normally no fense-sitter, but on this one, I have to come down on both
sides.  Oh, yes, I came down on both sides, and managed to get a wood
splinter in a very uncomfortable place in the process.  Ouch!  

June
None but the piper keeps up with the dancer!
   Siempre revelde!!
June