Harry/James, Crabbe or Goyle/Snape connection

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 100373


> Potioncat stated:
snip 
> Along the same line, Aunt Marge is floating out doors with her
> undergarments in view as well, much like the Muggles in GoF. So the
> audience is laughing at these two scenes, but should be shocked at
> the canon episodes.....I'm not sure how that is going to play."
> 
> 
> Kyntor replies:
> 
> JKR could be trying tell us something with this scene.  Maybe she 
is 
> trying to say that we are taking the scene between Snape and James 
> too seriously. 

Potioncat:
Sorry, I wasn't very clear.  How Marge is shown in the movie is 
different than the book.  And having her floating in the air was very 
similar in the movie to the Muggle baiting in GoF.  The audience 
found both Marge and Crabbe/Goyle funny...but when similar things 
happen in the books, they are not funny.
Potioncat