Is there anyone in that year who wasn't in love with Lily?

[amanitamuscaria1]

No: HPFGUIDX 100439

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ladyramkin2000" 
<ladyramkin2000 at y...> wrote:
> I'm sure Lily Evans was a delightful and loveable girl.  James 
> certainly fell in love with her, Snape possibly did (don't go along 
> with that myself, but a lot a people do) and now Lupin is suggested 
> as another who fell under her spell.  I have not so far heard it 
> suggested that Sirius was another undeclared lover and am wondering 
> if anyone has any ideas about how he felt about Lily. I would think 
> he might have been  a bit jealous of her, considering how strong 
his 
> friendship is with James (I'm NOT suggesting a homosexual 
attraction, 
> to bring up that tired old theme)but he must have been won over in 
> order to accept the posts of best man and godfather.
> 
> Sylvia

AmanitaMuscaria now - 
Sorry, all, but Lily is becoming the original MarySue for me. I hope 
we get some sort of dimension to her, and she doesn't end up as the 
idealised girl/girlfriend/mother she seems to be at the moment. Both 
Molly and Hermione have escaped the perfectness; Ginny and Luna both 
started out without it (hooray!), and Cho has blotted her copybook 
well and truly now.
Cheers. AmanitaMuscaria