[HPforGrownups] Re: Inconsistency in POA book (POA-movie spoiler)

[Alina]

No: HPFGUIDX 100477

> But if Animagi normally transform with their clothing on, wouldn't the
extra
> set of robes be an obvious tip-off to DD or anyone else that he faked his
> death?
>
> Barbara
> aka bd-bear
>

DD didn't know that the Marauders were Animagi, remember? At the end of POA
he tells Harry that while he was passed out after being attacked by
Dementors at the lake, he had a talk with Sirius and Sirius related the
whole story to him, including the fact that they were animagi.

"Remarkable feat, not least of it, keeping it from me." So DD, by his own
admission, did not know that Sirius, Peter and James worked out how to
transform into animals.

I also think that the bloody robes were left there on purpose by Peter, just
as his cut off finger.

Alina.