Harry as Kreacher was Re: Snape at school was Should Harry have told on DJU

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 100548

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "rowena_grunnionffitch" 
<rowena_grunnionffitch at y...> wrote:
Alla previously:
> > 
> > Actually, no, we can't agree that Snape had no responsibility for 
> > Sirius death'. :) As I said many times, I think that Dumbledore 
had 
> > much larger portion of said responsibility, but Snape is guilty 
> too, 
> > as far as I am concerned.


Rowena:
 
>    How? for making snide remarks? (his normal behavior). As DD says 
> Sirius is much too old to take schoolboy gibes to heart. 


Alla:

For not resuming Occlumency lessons. For leaving Harry defenseless to 
Voldemort attack. For not using his bullying skills for the good 
purpose and forcing Harry to continue the lessons.


Rowena:

>    IMO responsibility for Sirius death sets chiefly on the 
shoulders 
> of the DE who killed him, with the treacherous Kreacher second, and 
> of course Lord Voldemort who concocts the whole plot third.
> 
>    Harry has some responsibility for falling into the trap, but 
then 
> he didn't have the information to know it was likely a trap.
> 

Alla:

I am putting the blame like that:


Of course Voldemort gets his fulll share of blame as number one, but 
if we were to distribute the blame among the good guys I would put it 
like that: Dumbledore - 60%, Snape - 25% and Harry - 15%.


snips.
>    Sirius was suffering from severe cabin fever and frustration 
over 
> not being able to do more for the cause. This was the fault of 
> circumstances not DD, not Harry and not Snape. It was this as well 
as 
> fear for Harry that led him to put himself in harms way.

I sad many many times what I think  about Dumbledore's forcing Sirius 
to stay. I twill be a long vent if I start repeating now. :o)


Alla