Harry as Kreacher was Re: Snape at school was Should Harry have told on DJU

[evita2fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 100613

 Kyntor wrote:
> 
>   Snape might feel he is justified in 
> doing this since he is trying to teach Harry occlumency, but what 
he 
> is not justified in doing is making fun of Harry when these 
memories 
> affect Harry.
> 


When did Snape make fun of his memories ? He asked *one* question 
about Marge's dog. He *never* made a reflexion about the Dursley. 
He's even paler after he have seen Cedric's death.

In fact the fact that he never said "A muggle?! And you supposed to 
save us?, in a toilet, tsktsk, what your fans would say ?", and made 
no sign of pleasure abou it, is strange. His acts and his silents are 
more talking than his words.

He even compliment him. A la Snape, but it's a compliment, from Snape 
to a Gryffindor, to a Potter!

And I think that he made indirectly something about the Dursley. 
Every year, someone see something about the Dursley, but noone 
thought to act.

This year, they finally told them two words. And this year, it's 
Snape who find about them (or mostly about DiddyKins). I think he 
said something like if  he didn't care, to Remus or Albus, and he let 
them find something to do. He doesn't want be find being kinda nice 
toward Harry.

Remember, he made a big fuss when he 'saved' Harry in the Shack, but 
his goal was Sirius' arrest. It was his first preoccupation. Proving 
that Remus helped him ( and he did, passively) was the second, and 
protect the children, not the last, but not the first.


But when he really saved Harry, in the first year, he never talked 
about it! He spent the entire year to play the guardian angel, and if 
Quirrel didn't have say it, we (and Harry) would never know it. It's 
not in his character to hide something like that. 

Why did he never told him "without me, you'd be dead before you turn 
12 !" ?

He doesn't want to be seen acting nicely for him.Now, is it an act 
for the Slytherin ( I don't believe it, he's naturally against 
Potter. And Gryffindor. And many things.), or is it an attempt to 
stay in his comfortable world, plus a fear to change from teen!Snape 
to adult!Snape?


Christelle