Who is the adult (Was: Who's to blame for Occlumency?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 100723

Alla: previously> 
> > How do we know that? I think that with the right teacher Harry 
> would 
> > have been much more succesful with occlumency (Who knows, maybe 
he 
> > indeed learned something from Snape too).
>


Rowena: 
>    Only if he wanted to learn and I'm afraid that Harry makes it 
very 
> clear he doesn't want to learn occlumency if it means ending the 
> dreams before he finds out what's behind the door. I'm not at all 
> sure it would have made any difference at all if Dumbledore had 
been 
> the one teaching him. Harry. Didn't. Want. To. Learn. So he didn't.
> >


Alla: 

Well, both of us can just speculate at this moment, don't we?


I would say that Harry. Didn't. Want. To learn. From Snape. So he 
didn't and it lead to disaster. He should have tried harder, but he 
was not the one, who set the wheels of the said disaster in motion.

 

Rowena:

Obviously Harry is going to 
> have to find a middle ground between complete obedience and 
complete 
> independence. But then doesn't everybody?


Alla: Too true.