Harry's summer in the 6th book
Meredith
msmerymac at yahoo.com
Sat Jun 12 00:00:20 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 100923
> > Now Phil chimes in:
> > 2. And if DD makes it known that Duddy is a wizard, shouldn't he
> start
> > attending Hogwarts as a first year student?
> >
>
Bowlwoman:
>
> I don't know if Dudley would attend Hogwarts or not. It's a
tricky
> business, given the time parameters involved. We know Hagrid was
> expelled during his 3rd year and was told not to do magic w/o
> permission. That doesn't mean he CAN'T do it or doesn't know the
> correct incantations, only that he's legally prohibited. Since it
is
> possible for students to leave Hogwarts after their 5th year, I
don't
> know that the MoM could force Dudley to attend. It would be in
his
> best interest, no doubt, but he could always be tutored by someone
to
> get the basics. Can you see Harry trying to teach Dudley to
levitate
> something? :)
>
> bowlwoman
Luckie:
I take no credit for this idea, and I don't necessarily believe in
it, but some people on this list think only the best wizards go to
Hogwarts - are that there are a lot of wizards who don't. Hogwarts
is therefore the eqivalent of a top-notch muggle school, while other
kids just go to "Trade school." Maybe, if this is the case, we can
see what happens to untrained wizards - at least untrained by
hogwarts.
~Luckie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive