First Post...What if Dumbledore exists out of the 4 dimensional WW?

iclavenderstarz pink_sugar_melody_17 at hotmail.com
Sat Jun 12 00:07:50 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 100928

Well, this is here is my first post even though I've been lurking 
here for quite awhile.  I know that there are theories that Ron= DD 
and they provide sufficient amount of canonical evidence for their 
theories.  Although I do believe that this theory is really strong, I 
came upon an idea that some may have already presented but I haven't 
read while lurking for the past few months. Okay
 This all just 
speculation that came to me as I was washing dishes earlier
.

I was rereading a book by Kurt Vonnegut called "The Sirens of Titan" 
and there was a man who exist out of space and time.  He was 
described as a wave that blips in and out of the specific timeline.  
He is a man who seems to know everything and even causes things to 
happen to one person.  He is all knowing because he has been there or 
he caused these things to happen.  Now I was thinking, what if DD 
also exist out of the 4 dimension of things?

We all know that DD defeated the evil wizard Grindenwald in 1945.  At 
this time, Tom Riddle was also in school and wrote in his diary that 
DD had auburn hair then and taught transfiguration.  Yet DD, said in 
his youth he had eaten a vomit flavored Bertie Bott's Every Flavored 
Bean.  Also, one of the OWLS administers said that he oversaw DD's 
OWLS himself.  DD is over a hundred years old and this OWLS overseer 
should be at least 20-30 years older
 wait I don't even know how old 
you have to be to give those test
. I guess if DD exists out of time 
and space he could exist as a child or an old man in any part of the 
timeline that the books run.  Maybe Grindenwald place him in that 
existence?

I know this theory is bogus but Ron= DD is the only theory out there 
that I have read that would suffice as explanations to certain 
inconsistencies with DD's existence.

Lavender, a person who thinks that Dumbledore already knows the 
entire future of the Wizarding World therefore allows him to leave 
Hogwarts once in a while
.   







More information about the HPforGrownups archive