Harry as Kreacher

[Jacqui]

No: HPFGUIDX 101099

> Just a small point here: when exactly did Kreacher serve Sirius, 
> fearfully or otherwise? He never did anything that he was supposed 
to 
> do - clean, cook, etc. All he did was skulk around, get in the 
way, 
> insult Sirius and his guests and generally make a complete 
nuisance 
> of himself. More than that, he did things against Sirius' wishes - 
> such as take away various items that Sirius wanted destroyed. 
> 
> Naama

Even though Kreacher may have not done things like cooked or clean 
it stated in OOP that if he was given a direct order he could not 
disobey it.  That is why he left around Christmas time to go to the 
Malfoy's...Sirius had told him to get out and he took it literally.