Snape & Harry
Christina in GA
clr1971 at alltel.net
Mon Jun 14 13:19:26 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 101224
>[Kneasy]:Snape *punishes* Harry? Some scathing comments, usually,
>>(though not always) when Harry has done something >particularly brainless,
or marks docked; marks, by the way that >don't matter. How many exams has
Harry failed? Zero.
Christina: What about when he purposely broke Harry's potion vial in OotP
and gave him a 0? That was done deliberately. Snape is not my favorite
teacher and I admit there is something more we need to learn about him. We
just broke the surface in OotP. But after so many years of unfair behavior -
punishing Harry & other Gryffindors when Draco picks on them, breaking his
potions vial, making those scathing comments (which do hurt a person, BTW),
well I wouldn't trust him much either.
Christina in GA - Visit my Ebay Store!
http://stores.ebay.com/pineywoodsbooks?refid=store
Use codeword *lampshade* and get free shipping!
________________________________________________________________________
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive