Snape & Harry

klmf1 KLMF at aol.com
Mon Jun 14 19:57:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 101243


Would just like to speak up on this topic, though it's probably already come 
up.....Snape seems to enjoy treating Neville in a demeaning matter nearly as 
much as he enjoys doing it to Harry.  And Neville doesn't "ask" for it unless 
you count being clumsy , forgetful and timid as intentional provocation.  

Could there be, to Snape's thinking, some kind of relationship between Harry 
and Neville that warrants, in Snape's mind, such treatment to both?  Could 
both Harry and Neville's reference in the Prophecy have something to do with 
this?  

Karen F





More information about the HPforGrownups archive