Why Tom? (re: wizard genetics and long-lived)
fanofminerva
drjuliehoward at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 14 21:04:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 101256
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "littleleahstill"
<cmjohnstone at h...> wrote:
> In COS, Diary Tom tells Harry that they are probably the only
> Parseltongues to attend Hogwarts in the last 1000 years. As we
know,
> but Diary Tom didn't, Harry's ability to talk to snakes is not
> innate, but was transferred to him at Godric's Hollow. So, if we
take
> Diary Tom's word for it, he is the only Parseltongue to attend
> Hogwarts in the last 1000 years. Is the ability to speak
> Parseltongue genetic? If so, that's one heck of a recessive gene-
> and why would it be activated in a witch/muggle mating? It
doesn't
> appear to be possible to learn it, considering the many gifted
> wizards who can't do it.
>
> We know Tom is the Heir because he can open the Chamber, but is it
> anywhere directly said that his mother is descended from Salazar?
I
> thought it was in COS, but I can't find it. Who did Salazar have
> this family with? Choosing Rowena or Helga would make Tom the Heir
of
> Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff as well, which seems unlikely, so can we
> assume a child born during his wanderings post-Hogwarts. Perhaps
the
> Parseltongue gene descended from Salazar through a very long line
of
> squibs, and was activated by Tom Snr's marriage to a witch. That's
a
> nice thought.
>
> Or could Parseltongue have been a gift of VaporMort? I like this
one,
> but Harry needed Parseltongue to access the chamber, so I assume
the
> same would have applied to Tom.
>
> Am I missing something here?
>
> Leah
I think this has to do with whatever (and I don't know what this is)
makes Tom Riddle the /heir/ versus /descendant/ of Slytherin. I
think his ability to open the chamber, not the act of his opening
it, makes him the heir. Why him? I asked the same in an earilier
post, and I personally do not think we will know the answer until
the end of the septology.
Julie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive