[HPforGrownups] Squibs and Kwikspell

[Antonia Maria Duchesne Siemaszko]

No: HPFGUIDX 101620

At 10:32 AM 6/16/2004, you wrote:

>Tana wrote:
>
>Eustace_Scrubb:
>My guess is that Kwikspell is exactly analogous--it appeals to
>"incompetent" wizards as well as squibs, people who feel their lives
>are empty because they can't do magic or can't do it as well as their
>parents/siblings/friends etc.  It probably does most of them no good
>whatsoever, but that doesn't stop people from shelling out their
>hard-earned galleons in the hope that it will.


I still maintain that a Squib is a magical person with a disability, or not 
enough magic, NOT an unmagical person. Otherwise Filch wouldn't try 
something like that, if he knows nothing will ever teach a squib magic I 
don't see him hurting himself that way..

VERY ODD QUESTION COMING. Okay Filch doesn't do or cannot do magic, EXCEPT 
that he communicates some how with the Kneazle Norris. (she has to be a 
kneazle even if its not said, otherwise she'd never be able to communicate 
with Filch the way she does.)

So. Could Filch be a Homomagus (um I'm making up a word for the reverse of 
Animagus here?) is he a Kneazle gone human by mistake? He is kinda cat 
scruffy? Of course he can't do human magic.? Does Norris protect him 
because he's her son?

End of weird suppositions.

Tana 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]