Snape vs. RW (was: Harry) (was: What if other teachers behaved like Snape?)

[shawna murphy]

No: HPFGUIDX 101682

Potioncat:
> I don't know what DD was thinking.  <snip> 
> He took a young man, rumored at 11 to be up to his eyes in 
> dark arts, who has the social skills of a rattlesnake, and was/is 
> a member of the Death Eaters and gave him a job TEACHING 
> children?   

Pippin:
> <snip> all those who are willing to oppose LV must be united. That 
> includes people who study the Dark Arts, have the social skills of 
> a rattlesnake and initially found the Death Eaters attractive. If 
> you are willing to risk your own safety to protect innocent lives, 
> then Dumbledore wants you on his side, even if your politics and 
> his don't agree.


Kizzanna:
 
I have been getting the feeling for a while now that Snape is a spy 
working on DD side, you know the light side, and that would explain 
why DD seems to trust him so much, didn't he also mention in OoP that 
Snape had a very dangerous job, I don't have my book, so I can't look 
up the exact wording. But that would also explain why Snape is a DE, 
and why he is so advanced in legilimancy. He has had to lie to LV on 
many occasions, at least that is my theory.