What's wrong with being bad ?

[evita2fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 102068

> Stefanie:
[snip POA/Snape/Sirius/Lupin and what Snape said in the shack] 
> Even though these didn't 
> come to pass, Snape voiced them all. He had thought about them. He 
> thought the were going to happen and was pleased with the thought.

Christelle:

And Harry thought to Crucio Snape. And I'm sure that he would have be 
happy if he saw it.
p263:

"Harry sat there staring at Snape as the lesson began, picturing 
horrific things happening to him...if only he knew how to do the 
Cruciatus curse...he'd have Snape flat on his back like that spider, 
jerking and twitching..."

"Harry imagined picking up his cauldron, and sprinting to the front 
of the class, and bringing it down on Snape's greasy head_"

Stefanie:
> Taking two lives into his own hands to end them? Is this excusable 
> as "dark leanings" within his rights? We hardly exuse Voldemort for 
> them.


But we excuse Harry for every dark thought. And about 'taking two 
lives', what do you think another wizard who never knew Sirius and 
Lupin would have done?

say Tom, the inn keeper.

He burst in a room where there are a werewolf, and a convinced and 
very dangerous murderer and three children.

And they said that the real danger comes from a rat. No difficult to 
think that the teens are under the Confondus Charm.

Black is wanted.

Do you think that he'll say 'hey why not, you seem like a nice guy!'?


And I wanted to add something about the Snape!lovers and defender. We 
know that he's not the nicer of the world. It exists worse. He made 
some good.

Snape is 90% bastard, and 10% salvage and Snapish 'kindness'. We know 
it. But we look the 10%. We let him a chance for this 10%.

Is it so bad? Does he deserve the death because he's not the best 
teacher? Correct me if I wrong but if DD support him, could it be 
because he see this 10% too?

I think Hagrid is dangerous for the children, but I'm not here 
saying  'hey, I hope he'll pay his mistakes!' and Binns is in way 
worst than Snape. They learn with Snape. they don't like it, but they 
learn. Binns bored his students to sleep since before his death. And 
noone begin a campaign to replace him with a competent teacher.


Christelle