What's wrong with being bad ?

[evita2fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 102069

> > Kneasy:
> > And sometimes it isn't. 
> > But it must be acceptable at Hogwarts - it happens almost every 
> > day. They do things differently there; within living memory 
> > (Filch) students were hung up, screaming, in the dungeons, Arthur 
> > received an unspecified but severe  physical punishment for being 
> > out after hours with Molly.

Then,

> Alla:
> Eh? It does not happen in Hogwarts every day or at least we don't 
> witness it. Filtch talking about physical punishments? Maybe he 
> just wishes that they existed.
>  
> Do we hear any other teacher ever mentioning them? Could you give 
> me a cite, where Artur received physical punishment, please.


Some already answered for Filch. I'd love to know how could be 
describe a detention which consist of letting 11 years-old alone in 
the Forbidden Forest to search something who could kill a unicorn.

But I'm here to the quote for Arthur, page 535 (the Third task, GOF):

"Your father and I had been for a night-time stroll," she said. "He 
got caught by Apollyon Pringle--he was the caretaker in those days--
your father's still got the marks." 


christelle.