HUGE evidence for time-travelling Dumbledore

[meriaugust]

No: HPFGUIDX 102178

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "hettiebe" 
<carol_sutcliffe at y...> wrote:
> I'm afraid this isn't entirely canon but please bear with me. In 
> Philosopher's Stone Dumbledore makes the comment about having been 
> put off Bertie Bott's Every-Flavour Beans by coming across a vomit 
> flavour one in his youth. Now, I've just been replaying the 
> Philopher's Stone game in which there is a side quest to collect 
> wizard cards and I remembered that Bertie Bott was on one of the 
> cards. I checked his dates and his card says that he was born in 
> 1935, at which time Dumbledore would have been around 85. Not 'in 
his 
> youth' even by wizard standards. So, unless a mistake has been 
made 
> in the game, Dumbledore MUST have gone back in time.
> 
> Aha!!!
> 
> "hettiebe"

Well, I guess that just depends on your definition of youth. DD 
could very well feel that the age of 85 was his youth, as wizards 
seem to live quite a bit longer than Muggles. And I don't know if 
the game cards count as cannon, unless it is a chocolate frog card, 
which we know to be cannon. 

Meri - a firm disbeliever in the DD is time turning theory